HOME THEATER & SOUND -- DVD Review



Naked City
March 2003

Reviewed by:
Rad Bennett

Format: DVD

(all ratings out of 5):
Overall Enjoyment

***1/2


Picture Quality

***

Packaged Extras
1/2

Sound Quality
**1/2
. .
Starring: Paul Burke, Horace McMahon, Harry Bellaver, Nancy Malone

Guest Starring: Robert Duvall, Sylvia Sidney, Albert Salmi, Dennis Hopper, Ben Piazza, Eli Wallach, George Maharis, Walter Matthau, Lois Nettleton, Theodore Bikel, Keir Dullea

Directed by: John Brahm, Tay Garnett, Buzz Kulik, Arthur Hiller, David Lowell Rich, Elliot Silverstein

Broadcast Release: 1960/61
DVD Release: 2003
Released by: Sony Pictures Television/Image Entertainment

Dolby Digital 2.0 mono
Full screen

"There are eight million stories in the naked city. This has been one of them." That voiceover would end each show of this hard-hitting 1960s television series. The city, of course, was New York, and all of the action was shot on location. It was inspired by the 1948 movie The Naked City, which had a cold, edgy documentary style quite innovative for its day. The TV show retained a lot of this style in its handling of police business. Investigations were methodical and gritty in presentation, perhaps even more realistic than those on today’s popular genre shows purport to be. Paul Burke played the handsome, idealistic young detective with a show-business girlfriend who, during the run of the show, landed a part in The Sound of Music. His crusty, "been there, done that" boss was played by Horace McMahon. They frequently came to blows over cases, with McMahon wanting to cut to the chase and lock up a potential criminal, and Burke striving to be sure the person was guilty before acting.

More Class Television

A&E has just released the final two volumes of the 1968 The Avengers season on DVD (***1/2). This was the last official season of the popular show, though it was to be briefly revived later as The New Avengers. For the ’68 shows, Emma Peel (Diana Rigg) was replaced by Tara King (Linda Thorson). Steed (Patrick Macnee) remained the same stalwart anchor as ever. So much brouhaha is justifiably made over the seasons with Rigg that the excellent qualities of the Thorson season are often overlooked. The plots and scripts were zippy, the dialogue crisp, the action fast, and the pacing often better than in earlier seasons. The best scripts were still written by series producer Brian Clemens. The standout on these two discs is "Pandora," an episode in which King is placed in extreme peril, as a prisoner in a house where strange things are going on. It reminds one a lot of "The Joker" from the ’67 season, in which Emma Peel is placed in similar danger. Close inspection reveals that Clemens wrote that one, too. No surprise!

The transfers on these recent DVDs are quite good, though the prints are not always pristine. When they are good, though, they are very, very good. Hot colors were a trademark of both the show and the era in which it was filmed. Take King’s apartment, for instance. Its opposing walls are painted in garish colors: teal blue and yellow, with purple and red accents, set off by maroon carpet. And the costume designers were most likely to dress her in something that contrasted totally with her surroundings, say purple or green. All of these bright colors will be a feast for the eye on a properly adjusted monitor, and they are handsomely reproduced on these DVDs. The overall effect is one of glorious clutter and every detail of it is not only colorful but also sharply etched in singular detail. The soundtrack, which carries, in addition to dialogue, Laurie Johnson’s all important music score, is clean and serviceable, with period distortion only cropping up now and then. Each disc has a set of still frames as well as a chapter search menu. The discs may be purchased separately as volumes 9 or 10, and are also sold as a set in a slipcase.

...Rad Bennett
radb@hometheatersound.com

The guest stars provided the more human element of the stories, playing people who resonated with reality: tortured, caring, complicated, and very true to life. Since the show had such respected directors and writers, it was possible to hire some of the best talent around for guest spots. Some of the highlights of the eight, hour-long episodes presented on the two DVDs (available separately as volumes 1 and 2): Robert Duvall, balding but still with some hair, playing a loser who must confront his past while holed-up with his opera-star aunt; Dennis Hopper as a tortured psychopath who sadistically tortures and murders young women to avoid confronting his needs; the gangland vengeance that polarizes two brothers played by Paul Stevens and Ben Piazza; and Theodore Bikel as a model husband and father who, unknown to his loving family, works as a hired killer. The scripts really let the actors to get into these meaty roles, allowing the audience to see what makes them tick and how they became the way they are.

The shows used innovative camera work for impact, and a compelling score by jazz-band-leader Billy May, both of which helped to keep the show very "New York." One could never watch this program and pretend it happened anywhere but in the Big Apple.

The DVD presentation is excellent, in as far as it goes. There are four episodes to each disc. The black-and-white picture has generally good contrast, and is pretty sharp and clean. It’s not as good as the reference black and white on something like Down By Law, but is not washed out like the usual TV late-show presentation. "Good" is the operative word. The mono sound is more like "serviceable." The overall level is a bit low, so you will have to crank up your volume control a bit. The dialogue is good, but the music could have a little more dynamic range, especially since it is so well written.

Overall, this is an exceptionally literate and enjoyable show, presented adequately. One wishes there were some extras, even a history of the show and biographies of the actors, but there is absolutely nothing at all beyond an episode and chapter menu. While missing those things, I have to be grateful that this show has appeared on DVD at all. This is no doubt thanks to Image Entertainment, always willing to take risks to put interesting, often excellent programming out for the DVD-buying public. Unfortunately, it looks as though these eight episodes are it. At this juncture, Image has no plans to produce any more volumes of Naked City. Do not write your Congressman, write Image Entertainment!

 


PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com

All contents copyright © Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.

HomeTheaterSound.com is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music and movie enthusiasts.