HOME THEATER & SOUND -- DVD Review



Monster


July 2004

Reviewed by:
Rad Bennett

Format: DVD

(all ratings out of 5):
Overall Enjoyment

****


Picture Quality

****

Packaged Extras
***

Sound Quality
****
. .
Starring: Charlize Theron, Christina Ricci, Bruce Dern, Lee Tergesen, Annie Corley, Scott Wilson

Directed by: Patty Jenkins

Theatrical Release: 2003
DVD Release: 2004
Released by: Columbia TriStar

Dolby Digital 5.1
Widescreen (anamorphic)

The press has made much about Charlize Theron’s transformation from a drop-dead-gorgeous actress into the world-weary, large-boned main character of this riveting biographical film. These writings miss the point. One is never aware of the make-up she used or the large amount of weight she gained to play the role. The viewer never feels that Theron is "made up" to look like Aileen Wuornos, a hooker along the Florida interstate who shot and killed seven of her clients. No doubt make-up and gaining weight helps, but the transformation comes from within. Theron simply becomes her character. Her body motions are scary as she lumbers clumsily like some Frankenstein monster, a person uncomfortable in and unsure of her own body. Her eyes always betray her inside emotions, as do her nervous tics and lip twitches. At one or two points, one can catch, as Aileen dreams of furtive happiness, the beauty lying beneath the rough exterior.

The Real Killer

Documentary filmmaker Nick Broomfield had made a movie in 1992 called Aileen Wuornos: The Selling of a Serial Killer. He showed the capture and trial of serial killer Aileen Wournos as a sordid mess, a media circus in which everyone was jumping through hoops to obtain the best monetary deal. Florida police officers were fired after it was found that they were working on a Hollywood transaction.

Broomfield was called back to Florida in 2002 to interview Wournos, who trusted him and would only grant an interview in his presence. Broomfield obtained her last words on film, then set out to interview friends, sexual partners, and family, coming up with a new documentary, Aileen: Life and Death of a Serial Killer (***1/2). This has been released by Columbia TriStar on DVD, concurrent with Monster, the celebrated film about Aileen and her tragic life. You can buy them separately or as a set.

The more recent documentary uses Aileen's case to make statements about injustice and the death penalty. It presents the issues of her case in a manner that will stimulate thought. One might not agree with the director's viewpoint, but one has to admit that he works his craft well in supporting it.

Broomfield asserts that his last interview with Aileen clearly shows that she was mad beyond reason, while his scripted narration tells us that three shrinks were able to tell Florida Governor Jeb Bush that she was sane after a mere 15-minute examination.

Broomfield further concludes that although Wournos did the crimes, she had severe mental problems and should not have been executed. By carefully editing and juxtaposing all of his video and audio information, he implies that Bush was eager to keep his execution rate up to that of his brother, George W. Bush, in Texas.

Broomfield presents a lot of frightening food for thought in this second documentary, but perhaps the scariest thing of all is watching Aileen at her trial. If you have seen Monster first, it seems as if a ghost has appeared in Aileen. One suddenly wants to say, "Wait, that's Charlize Theron. How did she get in the documentary?" Theron's performance in Monster is that great, completely blurring the line between reality and acting. She is Aileen. I recommend seeing this documentary and Monster as a pair.

...Marc Mickelson
marc@hometheatersound.com

Theron, who won an Academy Award for her efforts, interprets this role with inspired nuance. And who would have thought it; up to this point, Theron had been cast in frivolous films like The Italian Job, where all she had to be was pretty and perky, tasks I imagine she could accomplish in her sleep. Hers has been a case of underachieving. Theron has acting chops that rank with any of the greats, and one hopes to see her in better movies from now on.

Her Aileen is a battered, abused woman, who has become a prostitute because she believes she can be nothing else. Yet she still dreams of being better, and when she meets an 18-year-old newbie lesbian, Selby Wall, she sees an opportunity to go straight and live a life that includes a house with a white picket fence. In self-defense, she kills a prospective client, and that unlocks her hatred of men. She dispatches six more before being caught and heralded by the press as the United States’ "first woman serial killer." Neither the script nor performance excuses the murders, but they do make the viewer hate the woman’s actions more than the woman herself. The overall viewpoint is one of realistic compassion.

Christina Ricci is wonderfully boyish and naive as Wall, and Bruce Dern is reliable as ever, playing Aileen’s only male friend, a half-crazed Vietnam vet. The direction by Patty Jenkins is assured, and the pace is perfect.

The DVD transfer is close to perfect, too. The video image is clean and clear, with immaculate contrast. Several scenes take place in a dim but evenly lighted bar. Normally this would produce scenes where important detail is lost in shadow, but not here. The Dolby Digital 5.1 mix is very special, too. Composer BT conceived the score in the 5.1 format, and it immerses the viewer while strongly supporting the action on screen. Extras are skimpy, making one sure that eventually there will be a super deluxe set that will include this movie and the documentary Aileen, Portrait of a Serial Killer. As it is now, there is a decent production featurette (which gives the viewer a chance to see courtroom shots of the real Aileen), two trailers, and some lengthy discussions on the creation of the music score.

This DVD is a must-see for Theron’s performance, one of the greatest in the history of cinema, but will yield other rewards as well, and cause one to think about life’s circumstances and resultant fortunes.

 


PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com

All contents copyright © Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.

HomeTheaterSound.com is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music and movie enthusiasts.