HOME THEATER & SOUND -- DVD Review



Ice Worlds
April 2003

Reviewed by:
Marc Mickelson

Format: DVD

(all ratings out of 5):
Overall Enjoyment

****


Picture Quality

***

Packaged Extras
**1/2

Sound Quality
**1/2
. .
Directed by: Alison Ballance and Max Quinn DVD Release: 2003
Released by: Pangaea Entertainment

Dolby Digital 5.1
Full screen

One of a trio of DVDs that cover various aspects of modern Arctic and Antarctic life, Ice Worlds collects three 50-minute documentaries produced by Natural History New Zealand, Ltd. along with special features on the making of the series and facts on Antarctica. Viewed together, the three DVDs cover the Arctic and especially the Antarctic regions with incredible diversity, giving insight not only into the unmerciful climate but also about the people who study the secrets locked in the polar ice. Ice Worlds is particularly fascinating because it addresses "Polar People" as well as animals' "Life at the Edge" in separate films. A third documentary, "Secrets of the Crystal Ball," discusses the role that both Poles play in the global climate.

Sinfonia Antartica

For many, the focal point of the Pangaea Entertainment Antarctic trilogy will be a complete performance of Ralph Vaughan Williams Symphony No. 7, Sinfonia Antartica. The misspelling comes about from the composer’s use of the Italian title. The music started out as a score for the 1948 movie, Scott of the Antarctic, which starred John Mills as the intrepid explorer. Vaughan Williams became so involved with his composition that he decided to fashion its themes into a symphonic work for performance in the concert hall. As such, the Hallé Orchestra, Sir John Barbirolli conducting, first played the Sinfonia Antartica in 1953. It is scored for a huge orchestra, including, in addition to the usual strings, woodwind and brass: organ, piano, celesta, glockenspiel, vibraphone, bells, a women’s wordless chorus, and wordless soprano solo. In viewing this compliment, one can easily see that the composer was into combinations that would produce "chilly" sounds to evoke the broad, frozen expanse of the Earth’s coldest continent.

Pangaea’s producers have chosen to put this music, which originally accompanied a film, with a combination of historic footage and newly shot panoramas, including some amazing underwater footage of penguins gracefully swimming in opposition to their usual awkward image on foot. All the images match the music very carefully, so much so that it often seems as if the music was specifically composed to go with this movie, rather than with the original biography for which it is was intended. Each of the work’s five movements is preceded by a literary superscription. These are shown on screen so the listener can read them, as the composer intended. Unfortunately, they are accompanied by whistling wind on the soundtrack, the producers no doubt fearing to use absolute silence, which would have been more effective; a small fly in an otherwise first-rate ointment.

The performance is by the superb New Zealand Symphony, conducted by James Judd. Deborah Wai Kepohe is the soprano soloist. The orchestra plays as well as any that has recorded this gargantuan piece, and Judd fully understands the music’s ever-changing moods. The recording is very good for a compressed delivery method (Dolby Digital), with an excellent front soundstage, and just the right amount of surround to produce a live feeling. The bass is always solid and impressive, though the organ, used to such great effect in the "Landscape" movement, seems a bit understated and distant. Since this is a movie, and we are used to sound manipulation in the medium, it might have been effective to make the solo soprano sound a bit more disembodied than she does. However these are small gripes. Overall, this is a sound recording far above average for a DVD-Video release, and the video and audio marry way above other wannabe unions. If one must make program music into music video, it should be done this way.

...Rad Bennett
radb@hometheatersound.com

Throughout the DVDs, some interesting contrasts emerge: the Arctic as a place to live, the Antarctic for study; land animals like polar bears and seals inhabiting the Arctic, with sea creatures and especially penguins living in the Antarctic. There is also the obvious fact that it's summer in the Arctic when it's winter in the Antarctic, and vice versa. Neither is a place for the faint of constitution, however, even in summer, which has a different meaning for the rest of the world. Among the wildlife discussed, I can only marvel at the emperor penguins, which have to be the heartiest animals on earth. They live year round in Antarctica, with the males tending lone eggs that they cradle on top of their feet and under their bodies through the most frigid winter months. I won't soon lose the image of dozens and dozens of male emperor penguins huddling together in the extreme cold and dark of the Antarctic winter.

I admire the great care the people behind these documentaries took in producing them, not only by giving us a very comprehensive look into life at the top and bottom of the world but also by covering both regions with great depth and not much sympathy. There is something intrinsically fascinating about life in such harsh climes, and the filmmakers knew this, choosing to be matter-of-fact and not play up the brutal conditions. The image quality is good throughout, varying only when the weather doesn't  cooperate. All three DVDs were digitally remastered in 5.1 surround sound, and while this may interest some, it plays second fiddle to the majesty of the images captured on film.

Whether watched from beginning to end or a documentary at a time, Ice Worlds and the other two Pangaea Entertainment DVDs, The Crystal Ocean and Sinfonia Antartica, present a rich view of existence in the coldest zones of our planet. Get 'em all while they're hot.

 


PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com

All contents copyright © Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.

HomeTheaterSound.com is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music and movie enthusiasts.