HOME THEATER & SOUND -- DVD Review



Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex – Vol. 2


December 2004

Reviewed by:
Josh Barber

Format: DVD

(all ratings out of 5):
Overall Enjoyment

***


Picture Quality

**

Packaged Extras
1/2

Sound Quality
***
. .
Starring: Mary Elizabeth McGlynn, Richard Epcar, Crispin Freeman, Osamu Saka

Directed by: Kenji Kamiyama

Original Broadcast Date: 2004
DVD Release: 2004
Released by: Manga Video

Dolby Digital 5.1, DTS 5.1
Widescreen (anamorphic)

It has been eight years since Masamune Shirow's Ghost in the Shell debuted in theaters, and the sequels are starting to come out. There is the full-length Innocence movie; a new comic series, Man/Machine Interface; and a TV series, Stand Alone Complex.

Ever Stranger Animé

If Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex proves too linear for you, then you might like Production I.G.'s Dead Leaves, a show that revels in its insanity. Our two heroes wake up naked in a field with no memories of who they are or how they got there: Pandy, a girl with a strange circular marking over her right eye, and Retro, a boy with a TV for a head. They proceed on a crime spree to gather food, clothes and transportation, but get pinched by the law and are sent up to the lunar prison colony, where all sorts of strange genetic experiments are taking place. It's up to Pandy and Retro to engineer an escape and try to figure out just what's going on, all the while getting down to some funky lovin'.

American animé fans are no strangers to some of the weirder Japanese exports, like FLCL, but Dead Leaves creates a new level of unabashed oddity. The characters in the prison are all freaks, pure and simple. One of the prisoners is Dick Drill, an auger-bearing inmate who is just one of the many willing to lay his life on the line for the newcomers. In fact, most of the prisoners -- oddballs with descriptive names like Purple Turnip, Easter Island Guy or Hippopotobull -- seem to view Pandy and Retro in a messianic light.

There's a big showdown with the prison guards, two genetic mutants named 666 and 777, and with the prison's warden, the mysterious Galactica. Something's going on, but it's somewhat hard to pick out the story elements from the stylized violence and general lunacy. This isn't about plot; it's about being a crazy cartoon.

Dead Leaves is a one-shot story rather than a continuing series, and there are lots of extras on this disc: documentaries, premiere parties, video diaries, trailers, photo galleries and what may be one of the strangest extras ever: a half-hour drinking game called "Truth or Doubt." Yeah, I'd never heard of it, either.

The inclusion of the extras is mainly due to the fact that the disc has Dolby Digital 5.1 instead of DTS. Thank you! The sound is bombastic all the way through, and it is reproduced well. Dead Leaves is presented in anamorphic widescreen, and the image quality is great, with none of the errors found in GitS:SA.

...Josh Barber
joshb@hometheatersound.com

Set in the year 2030, Stand Alone Complex is a separate reality from the world of the film. Most of the characters are the same that were seen before, but the whole plot has been largely ignored.

Major Motoko Kusanagi is a cybernetic operative for Public Peace Section 9, a government agency that polices Japan's growing robotic population. In a time when anyone can be an android, it falls to Section 9 to deal with all manner of cyber crimes.

Though the episodes are now more typical police stories than a large-scale tromp through philosophy, none of the movie's distinctive feel has been lost. The crimes that Section 9 deals with are way out there: a tank that comes to life, murderous geisha 'bots, mass android suicides; but these "problem of the week" episodes are interspersed with a larger, continuing story arc. This is about a hacker calling himself the Laughing Man, who was responsible for a series of attacks on nano-machine companies but had dropped out of sight for six years.

Stand Alone Complex began airing in the US in October on Cartoon Network, but judging by some of the things that happen in later episodes, odds are good that it's going to be edited for content. If you really want to experience this show, DVD is the way to go. Volume 2 collects episodes 5-8, including two standalones and two Laughing Man stories. There is a brief segment at the end of the show featuring semi-comic interaction between Section 9's fleet of Tachikoma tanks. These segments have also been cut from the Cartoon Network broadcasts.

There is a lot of CG used in this series, and for the most part, it blends well with the traditional animation. However, the hand-drawn lines often get jagged around the curves, particularly during movement. It is not a terribly distracting flaw, but it is noticeable. There are some problems with color transitions, leaving uneven blocks instead of smooth gradients.

The sound is very strong. Its good dynamic range and isolated tracks work well to envelop the viewer. The English and Japanese audio tracks are both very good in terms of dialogue and sound effects, so whichever language you chose to listen to will be fine. The music, by Cowboy Bebop composer Yoko Kanno, comes through clearly.

There are extras listed on the back of the packaging, but they are only on the Dolby disc. Since DTS always takes up obscene amounts of space (without offering any substantive audio advantage), the disc I received for review had no extras. I can't find anything on the packaging to tell whether you have the Dolby or DTS version, just on the main menu, so be careful.

 


PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com

All contents copyright © Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.

HomeTheaterSound.com is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music and movie enthusiasts.