HOME THEATER & SOUND -- DVD Review



The
Sopranos
Season 6, Part 1


February 2007

Reviewed by:
Doug Blackburn

Format: Blu-ray

(all ratings out of 5):
Overall Enjoyment

****1/2


Picture Quality

***1/2

Packaged Extras
**

Sound Quality
***
. .
Starring: James Gandolfini, Edie Falco, Michael Imperioli, Robert Iler, Lorraine Bracco, Steve Van Zandt, Tony Sirico, Jamie-Lyn Sigler, Dominic Chianese, John Ventimiglia, Joseph Gannascoli, Max Casella, Aida Turturro

Directed by: Various

Original Broadcast Date: 2006
Blu-ray Release: 2006
Released by: HBO

Dolby Digital 5.1
Widescreen

This four-disc Blu-Ray compilation of the 12 Sopranos episodes originally aired in mid-2006 is a showcase for what is arguably the best drama series ever to originate on television. The Sopranos went out of the gate in its first season with a very strong start. Since then, there has been a subtle evolution of the episodes into an organic whole with such effortless plotting, directing, writing, acting, and editing that you don’t even notice the depth and complexity of the story telling.

More Blu-ray Discs

World Trade Center: Wow! There’s no mistaking this tension-filled movie for your typical big screen blockbuster. Oliver Stone puts you in the middle of the disaster, almost as if you were an invisible presence during the actual event. The excellent HD video resolution is greatly responsible, heightening the tension by showing so much realistic detail. The somewhat reined-in soundtrack fits the movie perfectly. This isn’t a demo or reference disc, but it’s a movie everybody should see.

Mission: Impossible III: Incredible soundtrack, perhaps the clearest, most transparent sound heard on Blu-ray yet. Video quality is also quite good, but the intentionally contrasty look of the film makes it hard to give top marks to this disc as a demo disc. Regardless, the movie did a surprisingly good job of grabbing my attention and keeping my pulse rate higher than normal for the whole movie. I liked M: I III more than M: I II but it was difficult to forget about Cruise’s public meltdowns over the last year or two.

Monster House: The image quality is stunning, making it the best looking Blu-ray video I’ve seen so far. The soundtrack is clear with lots of bottom-end energy interspersed throughout. This is really a movie for bigger kids and adults. It is a bit too intense and scary for the early-elementary grades and younger. Witty writing keeps older audiences connected with the story and characters. The animation places obviously animated human characters in a nearly photo-realistic animated world.

...Doug Blackburn
db@hometheatersound.com

To enjoy The Sopranos, you have to be able to handle five f-bombs per minute (or more!), mob executions, buck naked strippers, adultery, drug abuse, male chauvinists, petty theft, graft, prostitution, hijacking, prejudice, and a parade of dangerous but compelling characters. Those who are up for it are rewarded with one of the greatest rarities in television -- intelligence and storytelling on a grand scale.

Season 6, Part 1 is not my favorite Sopranos season, but it certainly exceeds 97% of everything else available on television in 2006. The cast is so good at playing their roles that a properly timed look tells the audience as much as 20 lines of dialogue. I would have been happier if two plot lines had been much shorter: Tony’s coma-dream and Vito does Johnny Cakes. But the surprises and changes in this season upheld the high standards set in previous seasons: Lauren Bacall and Sir Ben Kingsley f-bombing multiple times? Where else would you ever get something like that?

The picture quality of the Blu-ray discs is a little better than what I experienced when The Sopranos aired in 2006 on the HBO-HD cable/satellite channel. It’s a little sharper and shows a little more detail. While not quite up to the standards of feature films, the image quality is "good" but it’s not reference quality. The standard definition opening theme runs at the beginning of each episode. Once the theme sequence ends, there is a huge improvement in image quality as full 1080p video takes over. Compared to standard definition Sopranos DVD or cable/satellite video, the HD Blu-Ray video is better by a large margin.

The Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack is a little more transparent and detailed than the 5.1 sound delivered on the HBO-HD channel, but very close to, perhaps identical to, the DVD sound quality. The sound quality is just average by blockbuster movie standards. The sound quality rating is not because of defects, but because the sound is less of a focal point in The Sopranos than it is for a blockbuster movie. Even though this isn’t the most transparent sound and doesn’t have much going on in the low frequencies, The Sopranos audio is arguably "perfect" because you stop focusing on it immediately and become immersed in the storytelling without giving the soundtrack a second thought -- except when they break into yet another great music selection.

The only special feature included is commentary for four episodes. Only about half of that commentary gives you any insight that’s worthwhile.

I can’t think of a better way to enjoy The Sopranos than on HD discs. The DVDs are OK, but the HDTV image quality makes the whole experience even more vibrantly real. The set is also available in the HD DVD format. More seasons are promised in both HD formats for 2007.

 


PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com

All contents copyright © Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.

HomeTheaterSound.com is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music and movie enthusiasts.